Why Do I Keep Doing That? Psychodynamic Therapy, Explained

Some problems come back no matter how many times you fix them: the same argument with a different person, the same dread before a promotion, the same pull toward partners or bosses who feel familiar. Psychodynamic therapy starts from the idea that these repeats have a history, and that understanding it can loosen its hold. It is often pictured as a couch and a silent therapist, but the modern version is a face-to-face talking therapy, and it is used for common problems such as depression and anxiety as well as longstanding relationship patterns. This post covers what it is, six core ideas, how it differs from CBT, where the evidence stands, and a short exercise to try.

A therapy about patterns, and where they come from

Psychodynamic therapy is a talking therapy that looks at how past experiences, especially early relationships, shape the way you think, feel, and relate to people now. Its roots are in Freud’s psychoanalysis, but it has changed a great deal. Classic psychoanalysis could mean several sessions a week for years. Modern psychodynamic therapy usually means weekly sessions, sitting face to face, and can be short term or open ended.

It is not only for people with deep or unusual problems. Clinicians use it for depression, anxiety, relationship difficulties, and a sense of feeling stuck or empty, as well as for longstanding personality patterns. If your main problem is a specific symptom, such as a fear of flying, other therapies may be more direct. If the problem keeps returning in different forms, or shows up mainly in your relationships, a psychodynamic approach is often a good fit.

The starting assumption is that much of what drives us is out of awareness. We repeat patterns because they once helped us cope, and we keep them because we do not see them. The work is to bring them into view, understand where they came from, and gain more choice in how you respond.

The model: how a pattern forms and how it loosens

Psychodynamic therapists work from a simple map. Early experiences shape what you expect from people and how you protect yourself. Those expectations and defenses then show up as patterns today, including in the therapy room, where they can be seen and changed.

Read the top row left to right, then follow the arrow down and read the bottom row right to left.

Six core ideas, one at a time

Psychodynamic therapy uses a handful of ideas that show up again and again in sessions. You do not need to learn them as vocabulary, but knowing them makes the work less mysterious.

1. The unconscious

Much of what drives us, including motives, memories, and feelings we avoid, operates outside awareness. You keep taking on extra work and feel resentful, without noticing that you are afraid of saying no. Notice it: When you act and later wonder why you did, ask what you might have been avoiding.

2. Defenses

Defenses are automatic habits that protect you from painful feelings. Common ones include joking, withdrawing, intellectualizing, staying busy, and blaming. They are not flaws. Each probably helped you cope at some point. A manager answers criticism with a joke and never takes in the feedback. Notice it: In the first few seconds after being hurt, what do you usually do?

3. Repeating patterns

We tend to recreate familiar relationship dynamics, even painful ones, because they feel known. You are drawn to partners who are hard to reach, much as someone close to you once was. Notice it: List your last three conflicts or disappointments and look for the common thread.

4. Transference

Feelings and expectations from important past relationships get carried into present ones, including the relationship with a therapist. You assume your therapist is bored, the same assumption you make about nearly everyone. A therapist can use that moment to look at the pattern as it happens. Notice it: When you are sure of what someone thinks of you, ask where you learned to expect that.

5. Avoided emotion

A large part of the work is putting words to feelings you tend to push away, such as anger, grief, shame, or wanting something from someone. Feelings that are named usually lose some of their force. Notice it: Ask yourself which feeling would be hardest to admit to someone you trust.

6. Insight and working through

Understanding a pattern is a start, not an endpoint. Change comes from spotting the same pattern many times, in many settings, and trying a different response, a process therapists call working through. You recognize a fear of being a burden and, for the first time, ask a colleague for help. Notice it: Pick one pattern and one different response to try this week.

Psychodynamic therapy and CBT: where each fits

Both are evidence-based talking therapies, but they feel different in the room. CBT is a structured, skills-focused approach to a defined problem. Psychodynamic therapy is a more open-ended look at patterns, relationships, and feelings you may not be aware of.

CBT tends to suit a problem with a clear target, such as panic attacks or insomnia. A psychodynamic approach tends to suit problems that keep coming back in new forms, that show up mainly in relationships, or that are hard to put into a single goal. Many people also simply prefer one style over the other, and that preference matters, because people do better in a therapy that fits them. Many clinicians combine elements of both.

What the work looks like, week to week

A course of psychodynamic therapy usually follows this arc:

  1. Getting to know you. The first sessions cover what brought you in, your history, and the important relationships in your life.

  2. Talking about what is on your mind. Sessions are usually less structured than CBT. You talk about whatever feels important, and the therapist listens for themes, asks questions, and points out patterns, such as a feeling that keeps getting skipped or a situation that repeats.

  3. Using the relationship itself. How you feel with your therapist, including disappointment, trust, or the urge to please, is treated as useful information about how you relate to people generally.

  4. Working through. The same themes come up again and again, in work, family, and the therapy room. Each pass builds understanding and gives you a chance to respond differently.

  5. Ending. The ending is discussed openly, because how you handle it often reflects your patterns with other endings.

Sessions are typically weekly, and some long-term formats meet more often. Short-term versions pick a central theme and run to an agreed end point. Long-term versions are open ended and may last a year or longer. There is usually no formal homework, though some therapists suggest reflecting between sessions. Psychodynamic therapy can also be combined with medication.

Does it work? Where the evidence is

Research on psychodynamic therapy has grown considerably, and analyses combining many trials find benefits comparable to other established therapies. Studies support it for these conditions:

  • Depression. Short-term psychodynamic therapy has performed well compared with no treatment and about as well as other therapies in trials.

  • Anxiety disorders. This includes panic disorder, where a psychodynamic approach built for panic has shown benefit, and social anxiety.

  • Physical symptoms without a clear medical cause. Examples are chronic pain and digestive symptoms linked to stress.

  • Borderline personality disorder. Mentalization-based treatment and transference-focused psychotherapy are two psychodynamic approaches with trial support.

  • Bulimia and binge eating. Studies show benefit, though the evidence is more limited than for CBT.

Four caveats worth knowing:

  • The evidence base is smaller than CBT’s. There are fewer trials, many are small, and some come from the research groups that developed the treatments.

  • It is not clearly better or worse than CBT. Where the two have been compared directly for depression and anxiety, results have generally been similar.

  • The size of the benefit varies. Researchers call this the effect size: how large the benefit is, not just whether one exists. A treatment can reliably beat no treatment and still change how someone feels day to day only a little, so ask what kind of change a study measured.

  • Judge it by outcomes, not by Freud. Many of the original theories are hard to test. Modern psychodynamic therapy is supported by studies of how patients do, and the evidence is stronger for shorter, structured forms than for open-ended long-term work, where trials are harder to run and results are more mixed.

A five-minute practice: the pattern check

Try this after a moment when your reaction felt bigger than the situation, such as a sharp reply, a sudden wave of shame, or a day spent stewing over one comment. You will need a pen and a few minutes.

  1. Describe what happened in two sentences, facts only.

  2. Name the feeling, then look for one underneath it. Anger often sits on top of hurt, and irritation on top of worry.

  3. Note what you did in the first minute. Did you joke, withdraw, argue, apologize, or get busy? That is your usual defense.

  4. Ask what it reminds you of. When have you felt this before, and who or what does this moment resemble?

  5. Ask what you expected. What did you assume would happen or what the other person thought, and where did you learn to expect that?

  6. Choose one different response for next time, even a small one, such as pausing before replying.

Hold your answers loosely. You are collecting a pattern, not delivering a verdict, and one entry rarely explains much. A list of five or six entries often does. If a memory feels overwhelming, stop and bring it to a clinician instead of working through it alone.

Where to read more

Books can help you understand the ideas, but psychodynamic work happens mostly in the relationship with a therapist, so treat these as background reading. Good places to start:

  • The Examined Life by Stephen Grosz. Short, readable stories from a psychoanalyst’s practice that show how patterns and avoided feelings play out.

  • Why Do I Do That? by Joseph Burgo. An accessible guide to defense mechanisms and how they shape everyday behavior.

  • Maybe You Should Talk to Someone by Lori Gottlieb. A therapist’s account of treating patients and being a patient herself, which gives a feel for what the sessions are like. It is a memoir, not a method.

  • Psychoanalytic Diagnosis by Nancy McWilliams. Written for clinicians, but a clear, thorough account of personality patterns and defenses if you want more depth.

  • “The Efficacy of Psychodynamic Psychotherapy” by Jonathan Shedler (American Psychologist, 2010). A widely cited review of the research, written for professionals.

When to get professional help

Consider seeing a licensed clinician if the same painful pattern keeps repeating, if relationships feel stuck, or if low mood, anxiety, or a sense of emptiness lasts more than a couple of weeks or interferes with work or home life. When choosing a therapist, ask about their training in psychodynamic therapy and whether they offer a short-term format.

If you are having thoughts of harming yourself, call or text 988 (the Suicide and Crisis Lifeline in the US) or go to the nearest emergency room.

This article is for general education and is not medical advice or a substitute for evaluation and treatment by a qualified clinician.

Next
Next

What is ACT?